Questions & Answers

All of our seafood is processed and flash frozen as soon as it gets to port when its freshness is at it’s peak. This ensures the best quality and flavor for our customers.

There is a misconception that fresh seafood is the best quality and taste, but often this isn’t true. Between the time the fish is caught and the time you intend to cook it, that fish has been quickly declining in freshness. We think you will agree that our frozen seafood has an amazingly “fresh” taste!

We pack the frozen packages into a foam cooler, surrounded by frozen gel packs, then immediately send it off for 2 day shipping (usually FedEx).

We ship all products out on Tuesdays. We typically ship 2 day FedEx, so you should get your order on a Thursday. Orders need to be placed before Sunday to get on the shipping list for that week. 
See our shipping policy for details.

Please be sure someone will be available to receive the order and immediately transfer the seafood to a freezer.

If you live in Northeast Washington, between Kettle Falls and Deer Park, we are currently offering personal delivery, free of charge. Just choose local delivery at checkout and leave the best phone number to reach you.

Local delivery day is Wednesday. We need to receive your order before Tuesday to get it on the delivery list for that week.

The Finicky Fisherman has some of the lowest prices for quality seafood that you will find! And we only sell the best of quality, so when you buy from us, you know it will taste fresh and delicious!

Both our Halibut Cheeks and Sabelfish tips are discounted when you buy more than 5 lbs. Also, if your total purchase is over 40 lbs, we can usually get a lower rate for shipping. Just contact us with your order through phone or email and we will get back to you on lower cost options for shipping.